The case of the largest crypto bribe in the Russian Federation went to court
Details of the case of the largest cryptocurrency bribe in the history of Russia were announced on June 25 in the City Court of Balashikha. The prosecutor announced the indictment against former Moscow investigator Marat Tambiev. He is charged with several episodes of bribery in the amount of 7.3 billion rubles. According to the investigation, the officer extorted money from members of the Infrastructure Organization hacker group, who were previously sentenced to suspended sentences for illegal circulation of payment funds. Tambiev allegedly promised that the funds on the crypto wallets of the defendants in the case would not fall under arrest, and for such a service he asked for half of the bitcoins stored there. Experts believe that such crimes are possible due to the lack of clear regulatory regulation of how to deal with the seized cryptocurrency.
Long-term cooperation
The Balashikha City Court has started considering a criminal case against Marat Tambiev, a former investigator of the Moscow Central office of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation. He was charged with a number of corruption crimes totaling about 7.3 billion rubles. On June 25, the first hearing on the merits of the case was held.
Tambiev was charged with 15 counts of bribery, attempted bribery and abuse of office. Together with him in the case is his former subordinate Kristina Lyakhovenko. She is charged with one episode of receiving a bribe on a particularly large scale, falsifying evidence in a criminal case, and exceeding her official authority.
The former investigator was detained in March 2022-in the case of receiving a bribe from lawyer Roman Meyer. He represented the interests of members of the hacking group Infraud Organization-Mark and Konstantin Bergmanov and Kirill Samokuteyev.
From the indictment, it follows that Tambiev used his official position and helped hackers since 2020. Then he helped initiate criminal proceedings against the persons who robbed Bergman's apartment. The justice officer received 500 thousand rubles for his services.
Tambiev's cooperation with hackers did not end there, and later he repeatedly received multimillion-dollar bribes from them for hiding their activities from the investigative authorities.
Nevertheless, in January 2022, Bergmanov and Samokutyaev were sent under house arrest in a case of illegal circulation of payment funds. This case was investigated by Kristina Lyakhovenko and Tambiev at that time. For choosing a milder measure of restraint, the investigator demanded $200 thousand from each person involved.
Also, in the case of illegal circulation of payment funds, hackers seized hard drives with crypto wallets containing more than 5 thousand bitcoins. According to the prosecution, Tambiev suggested that the defendants in the case divide the funds equally, and transfer the part belonging to them to new crypto-wallets in order to avoid arrest of the cryptocurrency.
Later, according to the investigation, Tambiev again repeatedly extorted money from the accused, but they eventually turned to the FSB. To transfer the next tranche, the operatives prepared a dummy of funds in the amount of 26 million rubles and took Tambiev red-handed. Later, during the searches, 1032 bitcoins were found in the officer's possession. He kept the keys to the crypto wallet on his computer in a folder called "Pension".
At the first hearing of the court, Tambiev once again declared his innocence.
"I don't admit the charge categorically," he said after listening to the prosecutor's speech. — I consider this accusation offensive, and the facts stated in it are outrageous and one-sided. I do not intend to humiliate myself on the principle of "Don't eat me, eat them". I did not accept the concepts of honor and dignity for this purpose, in order to exchange them here.
According to Tambiev, the criminal case against him is aimed at" whitewashing programmers " and the seized cryptocurrency. And the name of the folder with keys to crypto wallets on his computer, he called a kind of working humor.
— During the investigation of my case, I read in the media that my cryptocurrency was seized. But I don't deny it. My job as an investigator is to find her, " he said in court.
In March 2023, the court sentenced the participants of the Fraud Organization Mark and Konstantin Bergman, as well as Kirill Samokutyaev in a case of illegal circulation of payment funds. They made a deal with the investigation, revealed the details of the crimes, pointed out to the operatives other participants in the crimes and got off with suspended sentences. And in June of the same year, the Nikulinsky court turned 1032 bitcoins (1.6 billion rubles) found on Tambiev's computer into state revenue.
Material evidence issue
Tambiev could freely dispose of the bitcoins seized as material evidence in the case, as the issue of storing such currency in a criminal case has not yet been worked out at the legislative level in Russia, lawyer Alexander Burchuk told Izvestia.
"Cold crypto wallets seized in criminal cases are handed over to the investigator directly on flash drives," he said. — Now at the level of the idea, the creation of a platform based on the Central Bank that will accumulate, store and sell the withdrawn cryptocurrency has been announced. But this is not regulated yet, unlike other types of physical evidence.
The lawyer noted that the procedure for storing gold, jewelry and cash is clearly spelled out in the legislation. Documents on the delivery of these evidence are duplicated not only in the criminal case, but also in the departmental accounting. Moreover, they are reflected even in mobilization plans and are written off to the city's military budget when martial law is declared.
"While many issues of cryptocurrency turnover are in the gray zone, the number of crimes related to it will also grow," the expert said. — In addition, the situation makes it difficult to resolve civil law issues, including inheritance disputes, as well as the execution of sentences.
Since 2018, there has been an increase in cases of cryptocurrency circulation to the state's income, Maria Yundina, a lawyer for Asnis and Partners, told Izvestia.
— In general, over the past few years, the number of criminal cases related to cryptocurrency has increased by more than 17%, " the expert said. — The main difficulties with the withdrawal of cryptocurrencies are related to the lack of legal regulation in this area. At the moment, the owners of crypto wallets are established in an operational way: the information carrier on which the cryptocurrency is stored (phones, cold wallets) is withdrawn. Data about the passphrase for accessing the wallet can be found during a search, clarified during an interrogation, or in correspondence.
The lawyer noted that the cryptocurrency seized as physical evidence can be stored on private wallets of law enforcement officers or the department's wallet, if such a wallet was opened. In her opinion, procedurally, all these actions should be formalized by a decree on recognition as material evidence with an indication of the place of storage of the cryptocurrency.
Marina Yundina added that to solve this problem, the Ministry of Finance is developing a bill to create a digital platform for storing cryptocurrencies seized in criminal cases.
There are no provisions in the criminal procedure law that equate cryptocurrency with property, said Artem Yablokov, a lawyer and partner of the Yablokov Brothers company.
"But since cryptocurrency has value, in practice it is still classified as property, and the courts have already begun to make decisions on the seizure and confiscation of cryptocurrency assets," he said.
The expert noted that if the cryptocurrency is in the wallet of a crypto exchange, it can transfer the currency within the framework of international agreements on legal assistance or at the request of Russian police officers to law enforcement agencies of a foreign country. But this will be impossible to do if the cryptocurrency is stored in the wallet of the accused himself. Then the solution will be to conclude a cooperation agreement with the accused, Artyom Yablokov believes.
In March 2023, the head of the government commission for the prevention of offenses, Interior Minister Vladimir Kolokoltsev instructed the Ministry of Finance to work out the issue of creating a digital currency platform localized on the territory of the Russian Federation and under state control for their withdrawal and storage in criminal proceedings. He asked to report on the work done by October 2024.
• Video:
https://iz.ru/video/embed/1717898
----
A hearing on the case of Marat Tambiev, the former head of the Tverskoy District Police Department, has begun in the Balashikha court. He is accused of receiving a huge bribe in the amount of 2.7 thousand bitcoins (over 7 billion rubles), which was first reported by the telegram channel of the Cheka-OGPU.
Rucriminal.info I found a few more stories from Tambiev's life that could turn into criminal cases.
According to the source of the publication, Tambiev felt a special hatred for the employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, although in 2011 he graduated with a red diploma from the Moscow University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. How did you manage to install the Cheka-OGPU and Rucrminal.info the joint work of lawyer Roman Meyer (who at that time still had the surname Kovalev, a victim in the case of a giant bribe) and Tambiev (at that time the head of the Meshchansky MRSO) began back in 2018. Kovalev R. S. received the status of a lawyer in the Karachay-Cherkess Republic and the work began to boil. How many people have suffered from the illegal actions of such a joint tandem for 4 years of existence, we hope the investigation will someday understand.
We were able to find out some circumstances of one of these cases, initiated back in 2018. For 6 years, the court has repeatedly returned without staff to deter obstacles to consideration in accordance with paragraph 1 of Part 1 of Article 237 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation and still has no final decision.
In the early stages of criminal cases of the Meshchansky MSRO, the defense of suspects/accused was carried out by a friend, comrade and hand-held lawyer Meyer-Kovalev. Tambiev felt so at ease that he could disagree with the legislation of the Russian Federation and with the words - "I do not agree with the Criminal Code" - gave instructions to subordinate investigators to initiate criminal proceedings, for which the Criminal Code does not provide for criminal liability at all (initiated under Article 291.1 of the Criminal Code with a less significant amount). After that, Tambiev agreed on the indictment, of course, after Tambiev, the Petty-bourgeois prosecutor's office did not even check the legality of initiating and other procedural actions in such criminal cases. In criminal cases initiated in the investigative unit entrusted to M. Kh. Tambiev, the detainees initially assumed that the lawyer" defender " Meyer (Kovalev) arrived in accordance with Article 51, but the status of a lawyer in the KCR and the so - called "Roulette" introduced prevented the client from legally joining the case under Article 51. With the status of Meyer, the issue was later resolved, having received the status of a lawyer in the Moscow region, and then in Moscow, and, according to information on the website of the Ministry of Justice, the status of a lawyer is still valid.
Under Lawyer Meyer, the investigator managed to conduct inspections of objects, interrogate suspects/accused in his absence, and only then, with the assistance of R. S. Meyer, they slipped these documents to the poor guys for signature. Confessions were also changed and rewritten, printed ones appeared from handwritten ones, but sometimes they were in such a hurry that they forgot to indicate the name "surrender" or, to make it easier to "slip" for the signature, and Tambiev managed to write out the procedure in hindsight. checks to investigators who have not yet come to his service. If the material evidence contradicted the accusation, it was hidden in other criminal cases along with inspections or even thrown out in the trash next to the building of the Investigative Committee, and upon the fact of loss of material evidence, including in particularly serious cases, a decision was made to refuse to initiate criminal proceedings under Part 1 of Article 158 of the Criminal Code (theft) in connection with the fact that the investigative body did not find any elements of a crime in the actions of "unidentified" persons.
Employees of the OSB of the Department of Internal Affairs of the Central Administrative District of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia in Moscow (one of them studied with Tambiev in a higher educational institution) without verification materials, regardless of the territory of detention, were sent to the Meshchansky MRSO in Moscow to Tambiev. The employee of the OSB Department of Internal Affairs for the Central Administrative District of Moscow did not disdain to engage in falsification in 2018, the material was transferred "in good hands", forged signatures of witnesses during the OPM, changed the content of the provided correspondence in messengers, destroyed audio recordings that contradict the alleged accusation, and of course made reports "retroactively", describing in them those that had not yet occurred events… Before being delivered personally to Tambiev, the detainees were held in handcuffs for a long time to make them more compliant. there is no need to even talk about reports on the use of special means.
According to documents obtained by the CHEKA-OGPU editorial board in February 2023, the Basmanny Court seized 1,032 bitcoins located on two crypto wallets belonging to Tambiev. However, the latter also had accomplices. Another 1,032 bitcoins from members of the hacking group The Fraud Organization went to employees of the Department of Internal Affairs of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation. But they prefer to turn a blind eye to this.
Members of The Infraud were detained on January 18, 2022, the events were held by employees of the K Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation , Tambiev personally came to the place, since it was his department that initiated the case against the members of the group. If you "reverse" track the paths of bitcoins that have now been seized, you can see the following picture.
During searches of the members of The Infraud, employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the TFR gained access to ten crypto - wallets, which received 2064 bitcoins in December 2021-proceeds from hacking activities. At the time of the events, it was approximately 82.5 million dollars. Access to the wallets was provided by the members of Infraud themselves, most of whom the investigation, headed by Tambiev, then asked for a preventive measure in the form of house arrest.
Immediately after the election of Domarest and as soon as information about the detention of members of Infraud got into the media (the CHEKA-OGPU was the first to report this), on January 21, money from 10 Infraud wallets is transferred to one bitcoin wallet. It receives 2064 btc.
On March 7, 2022, it is time to " cut " this jackpot. 932 bitcoins and 100 bitcoins are transferred to two Tambiev wallets installed on his phone. According to the decision of the Basmanny Court, these funds were seized and transferred to the wallet assigned by the court on November 17, 2022.
Also, on March 7, 2022, exactly half of the funds (another 1032 bitcoins) went to the "cold wallet".
Earlier, sources of the Cheka-OGPU said that the" second half " of kush went to the employees of the K Department who took part in the searches.
According to the CHEKA-OGPU, the activities in relation to the Fraud Organization were related to the deputy head of the K Department, Police Colonel Boris Nikiforov, who was present at the search, the head of the 4th department of the K Department, Police Colonel Alexey Rykov and his deputy, Police Major Roman Chichin.
However, Tambiev did not find this kush enough.
After the arrest, the leaders of the Bergmanov group were extorted for money by their lawyer Roman Meyer, who stated that they still had to pay $ 1 million and 26 million rubles for the employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the TFR and the Prosecutor's office, so that everything would end well for the participants of Infraud. Then the Bergmans turned to the FSB of the Russian Federation and in a chain detained Meyer and Tambiev.
Basmanny court arrested bitcoins on Tambiev's wallet. However, the investigation into the theft of bitcoins by employees of the K Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation has not yet begun.
In March 2023, the Tagansky Court of Moscow issued a verdict in a criminal case against the leaders of one of the largest hacker groups, The Fraud Organization. All the leaders received suspended sentences and this is understandable. During the arrest, they had bitcoins worth tens of millions of dollars on their devices, which were stolen by investigators and employees of the K Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation. In return for their silence, the leaders of The Fraud were promised suspended sentences and the security forces, who became dollar millionaires, kept their word.
Bagish Rizaev (Mark Bergman)was punished by the servants of Themis three years and six months probation for Konstantin Sinichkin (Konstantin Bergman) three years of probation, Andrey Novak-two and a half years of probation and an Estonian citizen Kirill Samokutyaev - three years of probation.
As the CHEKA-OGPU found out, Bagish Rizaev (Mark Bergman) and Konstantin Sinichkin (Konstantin Bergman) met in 2006. During this period, their activities were conducted on the territory of Kazakhstan. In 2011 Andrey Novak joined them, and in 2012 Kirill Samokutyaev, a citizen of Estonia, joined their team. Immediately after that, they move all their work to Moscow and launch a market place “UNICVV.RU”. On this resource, any registered user, having replenished the balance of their account, could purchase stolen bank card data and foreign social security numbers.
Until 2016, the monthly cash turnover was about $ 100,000, and since 2016 it has grown to $ 3,000,000 per month.
Sources of the Cheka-OGPU said that Nikita Potapov, a senior operative of the 1st department of the SSB of the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation for Moscow and the Moscow region, was responsible for the security of the group and supervised its activities.
After the meeting between Putin and Biden, the go-ahead went to work on all major hacker groups from Russia, and The Infraud got its turn.
During searches of the members of The Infraud, employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the TFR gained access to ten crypto - wallets, which received 2064 bitcoins in December 2021-proceeds from hacking activities. At the time of the events, it was approximately 82.5 million dollars. Access to the wallets was provided by the members of Infraud themselves, most of whom the investigation, headed by the head of the Tverskoy District Police Department, Marat Tambiev, then asked for a preventive measure in the form of house arrest.
It is worth noting that shady stores selling stolen credit card data of The Infraud hacker group have also come to life. Members of the group were detained in January 2022, at the same time the "shops" stopped working. In particular, on the website of their largest store UNICVV.EN a beautiful sign appeared that it was permanently closed by the Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation.
And now the store "permanently closed during a special operation", suddenly, came to life. The same thing happens with a number of other Infrastructure sites.
To be continued
----
The Cheka-OGPU became aware of the identity of the first "SVO volunteers", who were released under the new law directly from the pre-trial detention center in exchange for a contract with the Ministry of Defense. The source also told how this process is going.
According to the source of the CHEKA-OGPU, the contract with the Ministry of Defense in Moscow has already been signed by former investigators of the Ministry of Internal Affairs Andrey Chekirev and Andrey Shumkin. The first person involved in the case of fraud with more than 100 bitcoins. The latter was a subordinate of the former head of the investigative department of the Investigative Committee for the Tver district of the capital, Marat Tambiev, who extorted more than 1 thousand bitcoins from the hacking group Infraud Organization, and led the billion-dollar case of the former deputy Minister of the Ministry of Industry and Trade.
According to the source, both were confirmed as sapper riflemen of the assault company of the 752nd Guards motorized Rifle Regiment.
In the Moscow region, the list of candidates was headed by the former deputy head of the traffic police of the Klin district Dmitry Pisarenko. Recently, FSB operatives caught him with a whole arsenal in Solnechnogorsk. Having the specialty of a sniper instructor and experience working in hot spots is a direct ticket to war for him.
According to the interlocutor, after the adoption of the law for prisoners by the State Duma in March 2024, Instructions No. 269/49/1/220/1/4274/303/1-u/14/3611 dated 11.04.2024 (GP of the Russian Federation, IC of Russia, Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, EMERCOM of Russia, FSB of Russia, FCS of Russia) were sent to all departments, in which the algorithm for recruiting defendants in cases is described in detail to the war.
In fact, the investigator or inquirer passes the ward a pre-printed application form, where the transcript of the author's signature already begins with the word "private". The completed paper is sent to the military enlistment office (in Moscow, this is a selection point for military service under a contract, 1 or 2 categories depending on age).
After that, the investigator draws up a visit permit for two employees of the Point, who, instead of the standard VVC, conduct an examination of candidates directly within the walls of the pre-trial detention center. Separate military personnel are assigned to each isolation ward.
Further, a joint commission of the Selection Point and military enlistment office employees is formally held, according to persons from among the special contingent. There, the issue of accepting a specific candidate for service is resolved and even a position is assigned with the division to which he will be sent.
As a result, an extract from the protocol of the commission and a request for suspension of the case against the person involved, signed by the head of the Selection Point for military service under the contract, Major Ivan Tekuchev, are sent to the investigator, who makes a corresponding decision.