Card-on-File Tokenization: Why a Saved Card is Safer Than a New One

[BadB]

How repeat payments lower your fraud score using history

Introduction: Trust Built Over Time​

You're trying to pay for a subscription to a new service. You enter your card details and get a "Declined" message.
The next day, you return to the same website, click "Pay with saved card", and the payment goes through instantly.

Why?
Because a saved card (Card-on-File) isn't just convenience. It's a proof of trust, built through transaction history. Fraud engines (Forter, Sift, Riskified) reward loyalty and punish novelty.

In this article, we'll explore how Card-on-File Tokenization works, why it reduces your fraud score, and how to use this mechanism to your advantage.

Part 1: What is Card-on-File Tokenization?​

Technical definition​

Card-on-File (CoF) is the process of securely storing card data at a merchant for future transactions.
Modern systems use tokenization:

• The actual PAN is never stored.
• Instead, a unique token linked to the user's account is used.

Example:

• Your card: 4571 7300 1234 5678,
• Token in the Netflix system: tok_abc123xyz789,
• When making a repeat payment, only the token is used.

Part 2: Why CoF Lowers Fraud Score​

Three levels of trust​

1. Transaction history

• Successful first transaction = trust baseline,
• Each subsequent payment strengthens the profile,
• After 3-5 transactions, the fraud score drops by 40-60%.

2. Consistency of behavior

• Repeated payments occur from the same device, IP, browser,
• This forms a stable behavioral graph,
• Fraud engines see: “This is the same user”.

3. Lack of 3D Secure

• Repeat payments are often exempt from 3DS (SCA exemption),
• Because the risk is considered low due to history.

Field data (2026):

• New card: fraud score = 85–95,
• Saved card (3+ transactions): fraud score = 20–35

Part 3: How Recurring Payments Work​

Two types of CoF payments​

1. Merchant-Initiated Transactions (MIT)

• Initiated by the merchant (e.g. monthly subscription),
• Doesn't require 3DS,
• Have the lowest fraud score.

2. Customer-Initiated Transactions (CIT)

• Initiated by the user (for example, “Pay now” in your personal account),
• May require 3DS,
• Fraud score is higher than MIT, but lower than the new card.

Key Insight:
MIT is the gold standard for legitimate operations.

Part 4: How to Use CoF to Your Advantage​

Building Trust Strategy​

Step 1: Choose the right service

• Automatically renewingsubscriptions:
  • Netflix, Spotify, Adobe Creative Cloud,
  • Game subscriptions (Xbox Game Pass, PlayStation Plus).

Step 2: Complete your first transaction successfully

• Use a low amount (<$10),
• Make sure the payment went through without 3DS,
• This creates a baseline of trust.

Step 3: Wait for the automatic debit

• After 30 days, the service will write off the payment as MIT,
• Fraud score will be minimal.

Step 4: Scale

• After 2-3 successful write-offs, you can increase the amount (for example, change the tariff),
• Or use the same card on other services with CoF.

Example:

• Month 1: $9.99 (Spotify) → success,
• Month 2: $9.99 (automatic) → success,
• Month 3: $19.99 (upgrade) → success.

Part 5: Why New Cards Are High Risk​

Three reasons for refusal​

1. Zero history

• No data to assess risk → the system is as cautious as possible.

2. 3D Secure requirement

• New cards almost always require an OTP,
• If OTP is not available → decline.

3. Geo-inconsistency

• Without history, the system does not trust IP ≠ card country.

Statistics (2026):

• New card success: <45 %
• Card Save Success Rate: >85%

Part 6: Practical Recommendations​

For maximum safety:​

1. Use CoF only on legitimate services,
2. Start with small amounts (<$10),
3. Wait for 2-3 automatic charges before scaling.

Avoid:​

• Saving the card on suspicious sites,
• Reuse the card immediately after the first transaction,
• Change of IP/device between payments.

Rule:
Trust is built slowly and destroyed quickly.

Conclusion: Time is the best ally​

Card-on-File tokenization isn't just a technology. It's a mechanism for building trust over time.

Fraud engines don't like novelty. They prefer predictability, history, and consistency.

Final thought:
True security lies not in speed, but in patience.
Because in a world of fraud, every transaction is a brick in the wall of trust.

Stay consistent. Stay patient.
And remember: in the world of payments, time is your most valuable asset.