Best eBay Alternatives in 2025: Analysis in the Context of Carding

[Mutt]

Understanding Carding in the Context of E-Commerce​

Carding involves cybercriminals ("carders") obtaining stolen credit card details (often through data breaches, phishing, or dark web marketplaces) and using them to purchase goods or services online. The goal is typically to acquire high-value items (e.g., electronics, gift cards, or resalable goods) that can be converted to cash or cryptocurrency. Platforms with weaker fraud detection, less stringent payment verification, or fewer buyer/seller protections may be targeted more frequently. However, in 2025, most major e-commerce platforms have implemented advanced security measures like 3D Secure (VBV/MSC), AI-driven fraud detection, and strict seller vetting to mitigate these risks.

Key factors that influence a platform’s vulnerability to carding include:

• Payment Processing: Platforms relying on third-party processors (e.g., PayPal, Stripe) or those with limited verification (e.g., no 3D Secure) may be more susceptible.
• Buyer/Seller Protections: Robust dispute resolution and fraud detection reduce carding success rates.
• Platform Size and Oversight: Smaller platforms may lack the resources for advanced security, while larger ones like Amazon invest heavily in fraud prevention.
• Product Types: High-value, easily resalable items (e.g., electronics, gift cards) are prime targets for carders.
• Regional Differences: Platforms in regions with less stringent regulations or weaker payment security may be more vulnerable.

This response evaluates eBay alternatives in 2025, focusing on their features, security measures, and potential exposure to carding risks, drawing on recent analyses of e-commerce platforms.

Best eBay Alternatives in 2025: Analysis in the Context of Carding​

Below is a detailed examination of top eBay alternatives, their operational frameworks, security features, and how these might relate to carding vulnerabilities. Each platform is assessed based on its fee structure, payment systems, audience, and fraud prevention measures, with insights into why they might be targeted or resistant to carding.

1. Amazon​

• Overview: The world’s largest e-commerce platform, with over 310 million active users and a 41% share of the U.S. e-commerce market in 2025. It supports a wide range of products and offers Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) for logistics.
• Fees: No listing fees; referral fees (6%–20% by category); FBA fees based on item size/weight; Professional plan ($39.99/month) or Individual plan ($0.99/item sold).
• Payment Systems: Accepts major credit/debit cards, Amazon Pay, and gift cards. Uses 3D Secure (Verified by Visa/Mastercard SecureCode) and proprietary AI-driven fraud detection.
• Security Features:
  • Advanced machine learning to flag suspicious transactions (e.g., unusual purchase patterns or IP mismatches).
  • Strict seller vetting, requiring business verification and bank account linkage.
  • Buyer protection policies, including A-to-Z Guarantee, ensure refunds for fraudulent transactions.
  • Real-time transaction monitoring and mandatory 3D Secure for high-risk purchases.
• Carding Context:
  • Vulnerability: Low. Amazon’s massive investment in fraud prevention (e.g., AI analytics, velocity checks) and mandatory 3D Secure make it a challenging target for carders. High-value items like electronics are heavily monitored, and FBA requires physical shipping, complicating anonymous reselling.
  • Why Carders Might Try: The platform’s vast product range and global reach make it attractive for acquiring resalable goods. Gift cards and digital products are prime targets due to their liquidity.
  • Mitigations: Carders often fail due to Amazon’s strict verification (e.g., address matching, CVV checks) and rapid account suspension for suspicious activity. Testing low-value orders (<$100) to bypass 3D Secure is largely ineffective due to Amazon’s sophisticated systems.
• Best For: Established sellers with legitimate businesses; unsuitable for carding due to robust security.

2. Etsy​

• Overview: A niche marketplace for handmade, vintage, and craft items, with nearly 90 million active buyers and 5 million sellers. Focuses on creative, unique goods like jewelry and home décor.
• Fees: $0.20 per listing; 6.5% transaction fee; optional advertising fees.
• Payment Systems: Etsy Payments (credit/debit cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Klarna). Most transactions require 3D Secure for card payments.
• Security Features:
  • Seller verification with ID and bank account linkage.
  • Buyer protection for non-delivery or misrepresented items.
  • Fraud detection for irregular purchase patterns (e.g., multiple high-value orders from new accounts).
  • Limited payment options reduce exposure to unverified methods.
• Carding Context:
  • Vulnerability: Moderate. Etsy’s niche focus on handmade goods makes it less appealing for carders seeking high-value electronics or gift cards. However, custom or vintage items can still be resold, and smaller sellers may have less experience spotting fraud.
  • Why Carders Might Try: Lower transaction volumes and less aggressive monitoring compared to Amazon could make Etsy a target for small-scale carding, especially for unique items with resale potential.
  • Mitigations: Etsy’s 3D Secure implementation and seller-driven fraud reporting reduce risks. The platform’s community focus and buyer reviews also deter fraudulent purchases, as suspicious activity is quickly flagged.
• Best For: Artisans and small businesses; moderate carding risk due to niche focus and solid security.

3. Bonanza​

• Overview: A seller-friendly U.S.-based marketplace with 3.67 million visits in Q1 2025. Known for low fees and easy eBay listing imports.
• Fees: No listing fees; 3.5% final value fee (1.5% for sales over $500).
• Payment Systems: PayPal, Stripe, and credit/debit cards. 3D Secure is often enforced by payment processors, but not universally across all transactions.
• Security Features:
  • Integration with Google Shopping for visibility, requiring verified seller accounts.
  • Customizable storefronts with seller-managed dispute resolution.
  • Basic fraud detection, but less sophisticated than Amazon or eBay.
• Carding Context:
  • Vulnerability: High. Bonanza’s smaller size and lower traffic mean less investment in advanced fraud detection. The absence of universal 3D Secure and reliance on third-party processors like PayPal may create exploitable gaps.
  • Why Carders Might Try: Low fees and a user-friendly interface attract small sellers, who may not prioritize fraud checks. Unique or collectible items can be resold, and the platform’s lower oversight makes it a potential target.
  • Mitigations: PayPal’s buyer/seller protections and Stripe’s fraud tools help, but Bonanza’s smaller scale limits proactive monitoring. Carders may test low-value orders to identify non-3D Secure transactions.
• Best For: Small businesses seeking low fees; higher carding risk due to limited security resources.

4. Facebook Marketplace​

• Overview: A C2C platform with over 2.9 billion monthly active users, ideal for local and shipped sales of used goods.
• Fees: No listing fees for personal sellers; 5% fee for shipped items.
• Payment Systems: Cash for local pickup; credit/debit cards or PayPal for shipped items. 3D Secure is applied inconsistently, depending on the payment processor.
• Security Features:
  • Basic seller verification via Facebook profile.
  • Limited buyer protection compared to eBay or Amazon.
  • Reporting mechanisms for suspicious activity, but minimal proactive fraud detection.
• Carding Context:
  • Vulnerability: High. The platform’s minimal seller protections and lack of robust fraud detection make it a prime target for carding, especially for shipped items. Local sales with cash reduce carding risk but limit scalability.
  • Why Carders Might Try: The massive user base and lax oversight allow carders to blend in. High-value used items (e.g., electronics, furniture) are attractive for resale.
  • Mitigations: Inconsistent 3D Secure and limited customer support increase risks. Buyers and sellers must rely on self-reported disputes, which carders can exploit by creating fake profiles.
• Best For: Local sellers of used goods; high carding risk due to minimal security.

5. Shopify​

• Overview: A platform for creating standalone online stores, with plans starting at $29/month. Sellers drive their own traffic and manage payments.
• Fees: $29–$299/month; transaction fees (0.5%–2% without Shopify Payments); no marketplace audience.
• Payment Systems: Shopify Payments (credit/debit cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay) or third-party processors like PayPal, Stripe. 3D Secure is standard with Shopify Payments.
• Security Features:
  • PCI-compliant payment processing.
  • Customizable fraud filters and address verification.
  • Seller-controlled storefronts allow tailored security measures.
• Carding Context:
  • Vulnerability: Low to Moderate. Shopify’s standalone nature means sellers must implement their own security, which can vary widely. Large Shopify stores use advanced fraud tools, while smaller ones may be less protected.
  • Why Carders Might Try: New or poorly secured Shopify stores (e.g., those without 3D Secure or fraud apps) are vulnerable, especially for digital goods or gift cards.
  • Mitigations: Shopify Payments enforces 3D Secure, and apps like FraudLabs Pro or Signifyd enhance detection. However, inexperienced sellers may skip these tools, increasing risk.
• Best For: Sellers wanting branded stores; carding risk depends on seller diligence.

6. Poshmark​

• Overview: A fashion-focused C2C marketplace for clothing, accessories, and lifestyle items, with a community-driven approach.
• Fees: 20% commission for sales over $15; $2.95 flat fee for sales under $15.
• Payment Systems: Credit/debit cards, PayPal, and Poshmark’s payment system. 3D Secure is typically enforced.
• Security Features:
  • Seller verification and community engagement reduce fake accounts.
  • Poshmark’s payment system holds funds until delivery confirmation.
  • Buyer/seller protections for disputes, with active moderation.
• Carding Context:
  • Vulnerability: Moderate. The fashion niche limits high-value targets, but trendy items (e.g., designer clothing) are resalable. Social engagement requirements deter some carders.
  • Why Carders Might Try: High-value fashion items and a younger demographic may attract carders, especially if payment verification is inconsistent.
  • Mitigations: Poshmark’s escrow-like system and community reporting reduce fraud. 3D Secure and delivery confirmation add barriers to successful carding.
• Best For: Fashion resellers; moderate carding risk due to niche focus and protections.

7. Walmart Marketplace​

• Overview: A growing platform with no setup fees and referral fees of 6%–20%. Leverages Walmart’s brand and fulfillment services (WFS).
• Fees: No listing/setup fees; referral fees by category (6%–20%).
• Payment Systems: Credit/debit cards, Walmart Pay, PayPal. 3D Secure is standard.
• Security Features:
  • Rigorous seller approval process with business verification.
  • AI-driven fraud detection and transaction monitoring.
  • Buyer protection and centralized Seller Center for performance tracking.
• Carding Context:
  • Vulnerability: Low. Walmart’s strict vetting and advanced security mirror Amazon’s, making it a tough target. WFS requires physical shipping, deterring anonymous carding.
  • Why Carders Might Try: The platform’s growing popularity and high-value items (e.g., electronics) are attractive, but robust security limits success.
  • Mitigations: 3D Secure, seller vetting, and real-time monitoring minimize risks. Suspicious orders are flagged or canceled swiftly.
• Best For: High-volume sellers; low carding risk due to strong security.

8. Newegg Marketplace​

• Overview: A tech-focused marketplace for electronics and gaming gear, with 8%–15% commission rates.
• Fees: No listing fees; 8%–15% commission by category.
• Payment Systems: Credit/debit cards, PayPal, Newegg’s payment system. 3D Secure is common.
• Security Features:
  • Seller verification and performance tracking.
  • Buyer protection for non-delivery or fraud.
  • Targeted audience reduces irrelevant traffic, aiding fraud detection.
• Carding Context:
  • Vulnerability: Moderate. Tech products are prime carding targets, but Newegg’s niche focus and security measures limit exposure.
  • Why Carders Might Try: High-value electronics and gaming gear are easily resalable, making Newegg a potential target.
  • Mitigations: 3D Secure, seller oversight, and buyer verification reduce risks. Newegg’s smaller scale allows focused monitoring.
• Best For: Tech sellers; moderate carding risk due to niche focus and security.

9. Mercari​

• Overview: A Japan-based C2C marketplace for new and used goods, with over 50 million U.S. users. Simple interface and broad categories.
• Fees: No listing fees; 10% commission per sale.
• Payment Systems: Credit/debit cards, PayPal, Mercari’s payment system. 3D Secure is often applied.
• Security Features:
  • Escrow system holds funds until delivery confirmation.
  • Buyer/seller ratings and dispute resolution.
  • Basic fraud detection, but less advanced than Amazon or Walmart.
• Carding Context:
  • Vulnerability: High. Mercari’s simplicity and smaller scale mean less robust fraud detection. High-value items like electronics are targets.
  • Why Carders Might Try: The low fees and easy listing process attract casual sellers, who may not prioritize fraud checks. The platform’s growing U.S. presence increases its appeal.
  • Mitigations: Escrow and 3D Secure help, but limited customer support and oversight increase risks. Carders may exploit low-value orders to test cards.
• Best For: Casual sellers; high carding risk due to simpler security.

10. eBid​

• Overview: An auction-style platform with lower fees than eBay, offering a familiar format for eBay sellers.
• Fees: No listing fees; 5% commission (or lifetime membership for reduced fees).
• Payment Systems: PayPal, credit/debit cards. 3D Secure depends on the processor.
• Security Features:
  • Basic seller verification.
  • Buyer/seller feedback system.
  • Limited platform-driven fraud detection.
• Carding Context:
  • Vulnerability: High. eBid’s small size and minimal security infrastructure make it a potential target for carders. Auction-style listings may allow quick, unnoticed purchases.
  • Why Carders Might Try: Low fees and a smaller audience reduce oversight, making it easier to test stolen cards on low-value items.
  • Mitigations: PayPal’s protections and feedback systems help, but eBid’s limited resources hinder proactive fraud prevention.
• Best For: Auction enthusiasts; high carding risk due to minimal security.

Carding Trends and Security in 2025​

In 2025, carding has evolved due to:

• 3D Secure (VBV/MSC): Widely adopted, requiring two-factor authentication (e.g., SMS codes, biometrics) for card transactions. Platforms like Amazon, Walmart, and Etsy enforce this, significantly reducing carding success rates.
• AI Fraud Detection: Large platforms (Amazon, Walmart) use machine learning to detect anomalies (e.g., mismatched IP addresses, rapid orders). Smaller platforms like Bonanza or Mercari lag in this area.
• Non-VBV Sites: Carders target sites without 3D Secure, often smaller or regional platforms. However, these are increasingly rare as payment processors enforce stricter standards.
• Gift Cards and Digital Goods: These remain prime carding targets due to their anonymity and resale potential. Platforms like Amazon and Walmart monitor gift card purchases closely.
• Regional Variations: Platforms in regions with weaker regulations (e.g., some Asian or Latin American marketplaces) may be more vulnerable, but global platforms are standardizing security.

Choosing a Platform: Security and Fraud Prevention Considerations​

When selecting an eBay alternative, sellers and buyers should prioritize platforms with:

• 3D Secure Implementation: Reduces unauthorized transactions by requiring two-factor authentication.
• Robust Fraud Detection: AI-driven monitoring and velocity checks (e.g., Amazon, Walmart) catch suspicious activity.
• Seller Vetting: Strict verification (e.g., Walmart, Amazon) ensures legitimate accounts.
• Buyer Protections: Strong dispute resolution (e.g., Etsy, Poshmark) protects against fraudulent claims.
• Escrow Systems: Holding funds until delivery (e.g., Mercari, Poshmark) reduces carding success.

For educational purposes, platforms like Bonanza, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, and eBid are more vulnerable to carding due to their smaller scale, inconsistent 3D Secure use, and limited fraud detection. Conversely, Amazon, Walmart Marketplace, and Shopify (with proper setup) are highly resistant due to advanced security and strict oversight.

Mitigating Carding Risks as a Seller​

Sellers can protect themselves by:

1. Using Secure Payment Processors: Opt for platforms with 3D Secure and PCI-compliant systems (e.g., Shopify Payments, Amazon).
2. Verifying Buyers: Check for red flags (e.g., new accounts, mismatched billing/shipping addresses).
3. Monitoring Orders: Flag high-value or rapid orders, especially for electronics or gift cards.
4. Leveraging Platform Tools: Use fraud detection apps (e.g., Shopify’s FraudLabs Pro) or platform analytics (e.g., Amazon’s Seller Central).
5. Crosslisting Strategically: Use tools like Vendoo to list on secure platforms like Amazon or Etsy, avoiding riskier ones like Facebook Marketplace.

Conclusion​

In 2025, eBay alternatives offer diverse options for sellers, but their susceptibility to carding varies significantly:

• Low Risk: Amazon, Walmart Marketplace, and Shopify (with robust setup) due to advanced fraud detection, 3D Secure, and strict vetting.
• Moderate Risk: Etsy, Poshmark, and Newegg due to niche focus and solid but not infallible security.
• High Risk: Bonanza, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, and eBid due to limited oversight and inconsistent security.

For educational purposes, understanding carding vulnerabilities highlights the importance of platform security. Sellers and buyers should prioritize platforms with strong fraud prevention, while carders exploit weaker systems.